A Study of Romans (33)
Paul feels we will understand “walking after the Spirit” better if he clarifies the contrast between those who live thus and those who live by the flesh, in enmity toward God, opposed to spiritual things. This he does by comparing the two “minds.”
Sinner
Mind means attitude, way of thinking, outlook, philosophy of life.
Carnal, as we have seen, means fleshly.
But here “the carnal mind” refers to the one whose inner man is dominated by the impulses of the flesh, thus clearly the sinner. The expression “the carnal mind” refers to the same people as those who “walk after the flesh” (8:1, 4), who “are after the flesh” (8:5), who “are in the flesh” (8:8).
He “minds” the things of the flesh (verse 5). This means he is interested in and attached to fleshly things.
He is dead (verse 6). This probably refers both to present spiritual death and to the destined eternal death.
He is an enemy of God (verse 7). This shows that a sinner is meant.
He is not subject to God’s law (verse 7). He does not submit to or observe that law, nor can be.
He displeases God (verse 8). Indeed, he cannot please God, considering his enslavement to flesh. Even his attempts at right doing are like filthy rags in God’s eyes (Isaiah 64:6)
Saint
Again, throughout these verses “the spiritual mind” is repeatedly set in contrast to “the carnal mind.” This “spiritual mind” is that which is possessed by the Christian.
He “minds” the things of the Spirit (verse 5). He is interested in and pursues spiritual things.
He has life (verse 6). He has been raised from spiritual death by the regeneration of the Spirit. He is spiritually alive and destined for eternal life.
He has peace (verse 6). This is in contrast to the “enmity” in the heart of the sinner. He is at peace with God (Romans 5:1) and thus has peace within.
He is subject to God’s law. Paul does not state this, but the contrast in verse 7 implies it. Romans 7:22 actually stated it, as did 7:25.
He pleases God. Again, the contrast implies this (verse 8). When a desire for righteousness comes from the heart, God is pleased. Such desires, when genuine, are motivated by the Holy Spirit, not by self-centered (fleshly) impulses.